Forget shoggoths. Penguins are the real heroes of cosmic horror.
At least, that’s the premise of new indie game, Penguin Colony, where you play a penguin caught up in the events of H.P. Lovecraft’s famous novella, At the Mountains of Madness.
In the original story, the Pabodie Expedition discovers strange, alien ruins on the Antarctic continent, and the remnants of a previous, ill-fated expedition. But what have penguins got to do with it? Well, they’re almost an endearing part of the original story. The explorers revile them, but look who survives…
While playing a penguin might seem like a gimmick, Penguin Colony seeks to deconstruct the racism of Lovecraft’s work by turning this Antarctic tale into a story of colonization. In the game, the original explorers are now Nazis, set on taking control of the supernatural forces that exist on the Antarctic shelf.
I feel uniquely qualified to talk about Penguin Colony, because much of my literary and game work has been in the Lovecraftian, cosmic horror space. It goes without saying that the worst aspect of Lovecraft’s work is the racism, and a lot of what I do as an editor and writer is thinking about how we engage with his work in the modern era, and how we centre voices that have otherwise been marginalised by his work.
So when a game engages with Lovecraft from a strong indigenous perspective, I’m immediately interested. If you take anything away from this review, it’s that I want to see more of this kind of interrogation of Lovecraft’s work from First Nations creatives. And despite some technical issues in the gameplay itself, it’s why Penguin Colony is important.
I took Genocide Studies as a subject at university, and referring to marginalised people as ‘animals’ was one of the key ways the Nazis dehumanised persecuted groups. Here, the colonized are quite literally penguins, but symbolically stand for so much more.
Notably, the penguins do not interact with the narrative, they simply see and watch the destruction of their biome. It’s a strong choice to tell a story as experienced by observers, especially in an interactive game. The penguins act as silent witnesses to Nazi atrocities.
There’s a part of me that wanted to interfere more with the Nazi’s plans in the Antarctic, although without turning this serious story into Untitled Goose Game. But I can also see why they don’t; in doing so, you feel some of the frustration and impotence of being unable to intervene when colonizers settle on your land.

While the penguins don’t speak, language is omnipresent in Penguin Colony. As you traverse the landscape, you collect shards of fragmented language and memory, in much the same way that indigenous languages have been fragmented by colonizers. The one constant narrative is the voice of Howard Blakely, who narrates over your explorations; slowly, the story unfurls of how he came to Antarctica and sought its power, in a tale of crumbling hubris.
Blakely admires the alien civilization of the Elder Things, built by their slaves, the shoggoths. US author Victor LaValle deconstructed this narrative in his short story, Up From Slavery, which is well worth a read if you’re interested in decolonizing Lovecraft. In Penguin Colony, the Nazis perceive the Elder Things as the original Aryan Race. Rather than portraying the shoggoths as monstrous, here they are a product of a natural landscape corrupted by colonizers.
Interspersed with these dialogues are the story of three Māori warriors who come to restore the desecration of the Antarctic wilderness. These stories are told in traditional language, and it’s an important contrast; English is the language of the colonizers. Much of the dialogue in these interstitials provides the context for what the developers are trying to communicate.

The Māori narrator emphasises the importance of art in resistance – a statement which can surely be extended to games:
It is the job of our descendants to carry forward the story of our resistance, to create song, dance and story, so our people move toward the light and away from darkness.
Unfortunately, the fragmentary nature of the storytelling and player’s lack of participation means that there’s less investment in the story’s outcomes. By the end of the game, I wanted to feel fired up; instead, I felt like I was only touching at the edges of what the developers were trying to say. And maybe that’s because, as a white woman, I’m not the intended audience.
But part of this lack of engagement comes from being told the story, rather than interacting with it. I think it’s an important differential, because players are more likely to experience change when they’re engaged. I personally enjoyed this interpretation because I’m familiar with the source material, but I wonder how different the game might be if you’ve never read At the Mountains of Madness.
Penguin Colony is more of a story experience than an interactive game. Some have rightly called it a walking simulator – or sliding simulator. You spend much of your time traversing the haunting landscapes of Antarctica, and while there are puzzles and points of interest, these aren’t essential to completing the story. You’ll often feel overwhelmed by the non-Euclidean angles; I found puzzles only to lose them again, or not have the ‘right’ penguin handy to solve the problem at the time.

It’s right that the world feels empty at times; Antarctica is a lonely place, and I’m reminded of games like Shadow of the Colossus that use this sense of loneliness to great effect. Navigating the world is sometimes wondrous, sometimes downright frustrating. The wind is a helpful guidance tool, but there are times when this sent me around in circles. It’s enormously fun to slide down snow hills as a penguin, but navigating the uncanny ruins of Antarctica becomes a lot more challenging when you’ve got two webbed feet.
Penguin Colony often hits the limitations of its narrative ambitions in its technical execution. Although the art style isn’t intentionally realistic, the animated scenes with people feel rough in comparison to the rolling landscapes. There is quite a lot of clipping, with costumes, outfits, and objects cutting through bodies, and the penguins often being able to walk through people and objects they shouldn’t. One particular cut scene froze on me and wouldn’t progress to the next chapter, so I had to do a hard reboot. I’d like to see more polish on this in future updates, so that the technical quality supports the storytelling.
But despite these issues, the modern Cthulhu mythos needs to be interrogated from indigenous perspectives. Penguin Colony asks an important question: when cosmic horror is often about fear of the other, what does that look from the other side? Penguin Colony reclaims what is unknown, and potentially fearful, and restores, bringing new light – and new wings – to a classic story.

Share your thoughts